| Pathlabs Marketing |
| November 18, 2026 |
Independent agencies are delivering for their clients. But the cost of doing that work is becoming harder to manage.
In new research from Pathlabs and Ad Age, 97% of independent agency leaders say they meet or exceed client expectations. At the same time, 52% report margin pressure, uncompensated scope concerns, or significant financial strain.
The work is strong. The business behind it is under pressure.
On November 12, 2026, Pathlabs joined Ad Age for The 2027 Independent Agency Operating Playbook, a webinar exploring what these findings mean for agency leaders heading into the new year.
Moderated by Natalie Zfat, the conversation featured Pathlabs leaders Cortland Fondon and Evan Ladensack, who explored five challenges facing independent agencies, from profitability and scope creep to AI costs, staffing decisions, and the growing importance of consistent execution.
Here are five takeaways from the conversation and what agency leaders can do about them.
1. Strong Client Relationships Don't Always Mean Strong Profitability
Client satisfaction is one of the clearest signs of an agency doing good work. But it doesn't necessarily reflect the health of the business.
The research highlights a disconnect: 97% of independent agencies report meeting or exceeding client expectations, while 52% are experiencing financial pressure tied to those expectations.
Much of that pressure can be difficult to see.
Senior leaders may spend more time managing delivery problems instead of focusing on strategy and client relationships. Teams take on additional requests without adjusting fees. Manual processes consume hours that could be spent on higher-value work.
Over time, those costs add up, even when clients are happy with the results.
During the webinar, Cortland explored why agency profitability is about more than pricing. Staffing, workflows, technology, and the way work moves through an organization all affect how much it costs to serve a client.
He also described the pressure placed on senior agency leaders when they're expected to manage the operation while continuing to deliver strategic work.
“They're actually building the plane while they're trying to fly it.”
The takeaway: Agencies need a clearer picture of what their work actually costs to deliver.
Start by reviewing profitability at the account level. Compare fees against the time spent on delivery, including leadership involvement, reporting, troubleshooting, and work beyond the original scope.
An account generating steady revenue may still be putting more pressure on the business than expected.
2. Scope Is Changing Faster Than Agency Fees
Client needs change. New platforms emerge, campaigns evolve, and opportunities come up that weren't part of the original agreement.
For independent agencies, being flexible is often a competitive advantage. But that flexibility can become expensive when additional work becomes an ongoing expectation.
According to the research, 86% of agencies say client conversations lead to scope changes at least occasionally. And while 21% experience frequent scope changes, only 8% report frequent fee changes.
That gap creates a familiar challenge. Agencies want to accommodate clients and protect relationships, but the work keeps growing without a corresponding change in compensation.
Evan explored how agencies can approach these conversations without turning every new request into a difficult negotiation.
Sometimes, offering an additional service at no cost makes sense. It gives the client an opportunity to see its value before committing to an expanded agreement.
The important part is establishing expectations upfront.
The takeaway: Treat added services as defined trials rather than permanent exceptions.
When introducing a new capability, document what's included, how success will be measured, and when the agency and client will revisit pricing.
That approach gives agencies room to be flexible without allowing unpaid work to become the standard.
3. AI Is Creating New Costs Alongside Potential Savings
AI promises to make agency teams faster and more efficient. But the financial impact is more complicated than simply doing the same work in less time.
The research found that 84% of independent agencies report increased AI technology costs. Nearly half, 48%, say AI has reduced expenses in some areas while creating new costs elsewhere.
Only 11% report lower overall costs.
Software subscriptions are just part of the equation. Agencies are also investing in training, implementation, connecting systems, and reviewing AI-generated work.
Cortland explored why introducing AI into an inefficient process doesn't necessarily solve the underlying problem.
Consider monthly client reporting. AI might help summarize results or generate insights faster, but if someone still needs to manually clean up data, reconcile numbers, and assemble reports, much of the original workload remains.
And when AI does save time, agencies face another important decision: what happens to those hours?
The opportunity isn't necessarily to reduce fees. It may be to reinvest that time into better strategy, stronger creative thinking, or more valuable work for clients.
Cortland cautioned that without a plan for where those efficiencies go, agencies risk losing control of the financial benefits they were hoping to create.
“If you're not on top of that problem, you're going to lose control of the profitability of your business.”
The takeaway: Measure AI's actual impact before assuming it's saving money.
Choose a recurring workflow and compare the time and costs involved before and after introducing AI. Include software costs, training, and human review.
Then decide how the time saved can create more value for the agency and its clients.
4. Flexible Capacity Is Changing How Independent Agencies Grow
Agency growth has traditionally meant adding people, building departments, and expanding internal capabilities.
But permanent headcount isn't always the best answer to changing client demand.
The research found that 62% of independent agencies use external execution partners. Among those agencies, 76% consider their partners critical or very important to their operations.
This reflects a broader shift in how agencies think about capacity.
Instead of building every capability internally, agencies are becoming more deliberate about which responsibilities need to stay close to the business and where outside expertise can provide support.
During the webinar, Evan discussed the importance of protecting the work that makes an agency valuable, particularly its strategy, client relationships, and industry expertise.
Specialized execution support can help agencies expand their services without taking on the full cost and complexity of building new teams.
Cortland also introduced a framework for evaluating new capabilities: rent, build, or buy.
Agencies can invest in software, develop their own internal systems, or work with an existing partner. Each approach has advantages, but working with an outside team can help agencies understand the opportunity before making a larger investment.
Of course, partnerships only work when responsibilities are clear.
An external partner should make the agency easier to operate, not introduce another layer of coordination, reporting, and oversight.
The takeaway: Evaluate new capabilities before committing to permanent overhead.
When demand for a new service emerges, consider whether an external partner can help validate the opportunity first.
Establish clear ownership, communication expectations, and reporting processes so the work operates as an extension of the agency's existing team.
The goal is to create flexibility without giving up control of the client experience.
5. Consistent Execution Is Becoming a Competitive Advantage
Independent agencies have long differentiated themselves through creativity, strategy, and client service.
Those strengths remain important. But increasingly, clients also expect agencies to deliver sophisticated work quickly, consistently, and across a growing number of platforms.
The research found that 70% of agencies say client technology expectations have increased, while only 29% say they consistently meet or exceed those expectations.
That creates a challenge for teams already balancing more tools, more reporting requirements, and increasingly complex campaigns.
Cortland explored how much of this pressure comes down to the processes behind the work.
When every campaign requires a custom setup, every report needs manual intervention, or a workflow depends entirely on one person, it becomes harder to maintain consistency as the business grows.
Adding another tool or hiring another person doesn't always solve those problems.
Sometimes the better opportunity is to simplify the work that's already happening.
Evan reinforced that point by highlighting how much clients value dependable delivery, particularly when small mistakes can undermine confidence in an agency's work.
“You can't always be the best. You have to be consistent.”
The takeaway: Build repeatable processes before adding more complexity.
Start with a core workflow, such as campaign setup, reporting, or quality assurance.
Identify where work slows down, where responsibilities are unclear, and which tasks are being repeated unnecessarily.
Standardizing those processes can give teams more time to focus on the strategy and creative work that genuinely sets their agency apart.
What Independent Agency Leaders Should Prioritize in 2027
These five challenges are closely connected.
Growing scope puts pressure on margins. AI introduces new costs while raising expectations for speed. Hiring can solve immediate capacity problems but create additional overhead. And inconsistent processes make every one of those challenges harder to manage.
The common thread is how agencies organize and deliver their work.
For independent agency leaders, preparing for 2027 doesn't necessarily mean making major investments or rebuilding the business.
It starts with understanding where time and money are going, putting clearer boundaries around scope, measuring the real impact of technology, and building a more flexible approach to execution.
Choose one process, account, or service line that deserves a closer look. Identify what's working, where the strain is showing up, and what could be improved.
Small operational changes can make a meaningful difference in an agency's ability to grow without adding unnecessary complexity.
Watch the Full Webinar On Demand
Watch Cortland Fondon and Evan Ladensack discuss agency profitability, scope management, AI investments, flexible capacity, and the role of execution in building a healthier business.
Get the Research Behind the Conversation
Explore the findings in The Invisible Bill: 2026 State of Independent Agencies.
Grow Your Agency Without Adding to the Strain
Talk with Pathlabs about how media execution support could give your team more time for strategy, clients, and growth.
Free Strategy Call